If you’re stepping into the world of pomades, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is oil-based vs. water-based. Both have their strengths, and the right choice depends on your hair type, styling needs, and lifestyle.
So, what’s the difference? Let’s break it down so you can pick the perfect pomade for your style.
What is an Oil-Based Pomade?
Oil-based pomades are the OG of hair styling. They’ve been around for decades and are known for their high hold, slick finish, and long-lasting wear.
Key Features:
✅ Strong, flexible hold – Doesn’t harden like gels, allowing restyling throughout the day.
✅ Signature shine – Gives that classic glossy look, perfect for pompadours, slick backs, and side parts.
✅ Resists humidity & sweat – Ideal for all-day hold, even in hot or humid conditions.
✅ Build-up helps train hair – Since oil-based pomades don’t wash out easily, they help keep hair in place over time.
Downsides:
❌ Harder to wash out – Requires multiple washes or a degreasing shampoo.
❌ Can feel heavy or greasy – Not ideal for those with fine hair or who prefer a lightweight feel.
Who Should Use It?
- Classic style lovers who want that vintage, high-shine finish.
- Guys with thick or unruly hair that needs extra control.
- Anyone who doesn’t mind a little build-up and prefers a more traditional pomade experience.
Lockhart’s Pick:
🔥 Goon Grease – The gold standard for oil-based pomades. Strong hold, high shine, and unbeatable endurance.
What is a Water-Based Pomade?
Water-based pomades are the modern evolution of pomade, giving you a similar hold and shine but with easy washability. They’re perfect if you want a strong style without committing to the greasy feel of an oil-based formula.
Key Features:
✅ Washes out with water – No heavy shampoos or special rinses needed.
✅ Variety of finishes – Can range from high shine to matte, depending on the formula.
✅ Firm, all-day hold – Keeps hair in place but typically sets harder than oil-based pomades.
✅ Lightweight feel – Doesn’t weigh hair down like heavier oil-based formulas.
Downsides:
❌ Can dry out faster – Unlike oil-based pomades, some formulas may stiffen up throughout the day.
❌ Less build-up – Good for those who like a fresh start, but not ideal for training hair over time.
Who Should Use It?
- Anyone who wants a low-maintenance routine and easy washout.
- Guys who like a cleaner feel without product build-up.
- People who switch styles often and don’t want yesterday’s product affecting today’s look.
Lockhart’s Pick:
💧 Water Based Goon Grease Pomade – The best of both worlds: the feel of an oil-based pomade with the convenience of a water-based formula.
Which One is Right for You?
| Feature | Oil-Based Pomade | Water-Based Pomade |
|---|---|---|
| Hold | Strong, flexible | Strong, firm |
| Shine | High | Varies (matte to high shine) |
| Washability | Harder to wash out | Rinses out easily |
| Restylability | Easy to restyle | Sets in place, may need water to rework |
| Weather Resistance | High (handles humidity well) | Moderate (some formulas stiffen in dry air) |
| Best For | Classic styles, thick hair, long-lasting control | Modern styles, easy washout, lightweight feel |
Final Thoughts
There’s no right or wrong choice—it all comes down to what works best for your hair and lifestyle.
- Want a classic, long-lasting, slick style? Go for an oil-based pomade like Goon Grease or Lockhart's Medium Hold.
- Need something easy to wash out with a modern feel? Grab a water-based pomade like Water Based Goon Grease or Paradox Pomade.
- Still unsure? Try both and see which works best for you!
No matter what you choose, Lockhart’s has you covered with high-quality pomades designed for all hair types and styles.
👉 Shop the full pomade lineup here and find your perfect match!
